Jim Fossel: Republicans give Democrats victories over crime and immigration

Over the past week or so, we’ve seen subtle changes from the White House (and Democrats as a whole) on a few key issues where they are losing ground: immigration and crime.

On immigration, Vice President Kamala Harris finally decided to go to the border after months of criticism from Republicans for failing to do so when President Biden made her aware of the matter . Her visit was mostly a no-substance photoshoot that won’t do much to stem the rising tide of illegal immigration, but it at least got her ticking that box off her list (although she didn’t visited the real border). That’s probably the most it’s going to do in this area anytime soon, anyway: the administration hasn’t put any real legislative pressure on the issue, and neither side seems very interested in finding a ground for it. ‘agreement. Republicans are too terrified of their own base to even pretend to be interested in discussing immigration, and Democrats seem sufficiently certain of their continuing majority not to be interested in negotiating either.

Rather than spending months criticizing Harris for his failure to do a photo op, Republicans could have presented their own comprehensive approach to immigration. It was also not to be the result of an endless round of negotiations with the Democrats, or start solely at the request of the White House, as happened with the infrastructure negotiations. They could have simply started with their own plan, which included a mix of hardened border applications and funds to fix the fundamental issues that caused the problem. Instead, they spent weeks harassing Harris for not visiting the border, so she decided to go ahead and visit the border. While that didn’t help anything to resolve anything, it did make it seem like the White House was doing something – and with most of the media on their side, that’s more than enough.

On crime, White House Democrats to the end seem to have finally realized that police funding – regardless of what its supporters say it really means – probably isn’t a winning campaign slogan. Instead, Biden apparently turned the tide, vowing to suddenly get tough on crime. Given that he holds the presidential bully chair, even though Biden is only capable of taking a few executive steps to tackle crime, that’s more than enough to counter Republicans’ attacks on the matter. Indeed, Biden and other Democrats can bring a new impetus to gun control, wrapping it in harsh anti-crime language that may well appeal to moderate voters on both parties.

Much like with immigration, Republicans failed to counter Biden’s speech on crime with a substantive proposal, again focusing on the rhetorical battle. They could have pointed out that Senator Tim Scott, RS.C., has proposed his own round of police reforms, negotiating in good faith with Democrats on the issue. These negotiations could also be used as a vehicle to fight crime, including measures to increase funding and other resources for police in needy communities while simultaneously enacting necessary reforms. Instead, Republicans seem to mostly ignore these efforts, rather than promote them or even use them constructively politically.

These two problems highlight a constant and persistent fault of the Republican Party in general, from the national level to the local level: constant criticism without any kind of substantive follow-up. With these two problems, the National Republicans failed to achieve a symbolic political victory or a substantial political victory. While they may like to congratulate themselves on leading the conversation by forcing Harris at the border and the Democrats to forgo police funding, in fact, they have done no such thing. Instead, they gave the Democrats a gift by pulling them away from politically perilous positions long before the election – and they got absolutely nothing in return.

While these kind of Pyrrhic victories can get politicians to score love points from their base, they are doing nothing to make positive politics or to grow the party in the long run. In fact, they often accomplish the opposite, making governance more difficult and driving weary voters away from all the negativity. Rather than scoring cheap political points and winning a news cycle, Republicans should focus on securing substantial political victories – or, failing that, at least presenting their proposals, so that Americans know how they would govern if they won.

Jim Fossel, a Conservative activist for Gardiner, worked for Senator Susan Collins. He can be contacted at:
[email protected]
Twitter: @jimfossel


Use the form below to reset your password. When you submit your account email, we’ll send you an email with a reset code.




Source link

About Therese Williams

Check Also

Republicans and Democrats in St. Louis County to try to compromise on redistribution map ahead of Monday’s vote | Politics

Both maps were drawn near the current dividing lines. The final map is unlikely to …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *